All My Dolls

Composition vs. Vinyl Shirley Temple Dolls: How to Tell a 1930s Doll from a 1950s One

November 18, 2026

The short verdict

If she is hard, painted and wears a glued-on mohair wig, with SHIRLEY TEMPLE on her head or back, she is almost certainly a 1930s composition doll. If her hair is rooted into the scalp and her neck reads "Ideal Doll" with an ST size code such as ST12, she is a late-1950s to early-1960s vinyl doll. The hair and the mark settle most cases in under a minute; the type of damage (crazing on composition, stickiness or color change on vinyl) backs it up.

Side by side

Feature 1930s composition Shirley Late-1950s to early-1960s vinyl Shirley
Years 1934–1939 (Ideal) 1958–1963 per Doll Reference and WorthPoint; some references, including The Strong museum, give 1957
Material Composition: wood pulp and glue, painted flesh tone Vinyl
Hair Mohair wig, glued on, set in ringlets Rooted hair set into the scalp (saran on the 1960 Playpal-size doll)
Head mark SHIRLEY TEMPLE, sometimes with Ideal Nov. & Toy Co.; earliest dolls COP Ideal Doll plus ST and the size, e.g. ST12; ST-19-R or ST-19-1 on the 19-inch
Back mark SHIRLEY TEMPLE, often with the size number Ideal Doll and size code on the back as well
Sizes Nine sizes, 11 to 27 in. 12, 15, 17 and 19 in.; rare 26 in.; Playpal size 35–36 in. (1960)
Eyes Hazel sleep eyes with real upper lashes; flirty eyes on some larger dolls Sleep eyes; sleep or flirty on the 17 and 19 in.
Construction Six pieces strung with elastic (metal hooks over elastic on a museum example) Not detailed in our sources beyond vinyl head and rooted hair
Typical age damage Crazing and cracking from temperature extremes; cloudy eyes Plasticized vinyl can develop a sticky surface; fluorescent light can turn vinyl green

Who each is for

  • Composition guide: for anyone holding a hard, wigged doll with SHIRLEY TEMPLE marks, the 1930s originals most collectors seek first.
  • Vinyl guide: for anyone with a rooted-hair doll marked ST, often a childhood doll from the late 1950s or early 1960s.
  • Both: for people who have inherited more than one Shirley and need to sort them by era before looking at outfits or value.

Start with the hair

If you only check one thing, check the hair. Part it gently at the crown.

  • A wig, glued to the head, with a cap or edge you can feel at the hairline, points to composition. The 1930s Ideal dolls wore mohair wigs set in Shirley’s ringlets; Doll Kingdom says the agreement with the Temple family specified 52 sausage curls, exactly like her own hair.
  • Hair rooted in small plugs coming straight out of the scalp points to vinyl. The Camelot Dolls blog describes the 1950s Shirley simply as made of vinyl with rooted hair, and Doll Reference describes the 1960 Playpal-size Shirley’s hair as rooted saran.

One caution: wigs get replaced over 90 years, so a wig that looks wrong doesn’t rule out composition. Rooted hair, though, is part of the vinyl head and can’t be added to a composition doll in the same way.

Then read the marks

The marks are molded into the material, so they survive when clothes, wigs and boxes don’t.

Composition. WorthPoint says that, except for the earliest dolls, composition Ideal Shirleys are marked SHIRLEY TEMPLE on both the head and back. Doll Reference records head marks reading Shirley Temple with Ideal Nov. & Toy Co., and back marks with the name in an arch or with Ideal inside a diamond. The very first dolls of 1934 are different: the Powerhouse Museum says that until copyright was obtained, they were printed on the back of the head with COP, for Copyright Pending.

Vinyl. The vinyl dolls carry Ideal’s name and a size code instead of Shirley’s full name. Doll Reference gives the 12-inch doll’s head mark as Ideal Doll ST12, where ST stands for Shirley Temple and the number is the size. Camelot adds that the mark appears on the back of the head and on the back. The 19-inch doll is the odd one out: Doll Reference records Ideal Toy Corp ST-19-R on the walker and Ideal Doll ST-19-1 on the non-walker.

So a doll that says SHIRLEY TEMPLE in full is pointing you to the 1930s, and one that says ST plus a number is pointing you to the vinyl era. Lift the hair at the nape and use a light held low across the surface; the marks are raised and easy to miss.

Feel the surface and the joints

Composition is a hard material made of wood pulp and glue, painted to a flesh tone. Kennett describes the composition Shirleys as six pieces strung together with elastic, and the Powerhouse Museum’s 22-inch example is fully jointed six-part composition held together by metal hooks over elastic. If her limbs feel loose and spring back when you pull them gently, that elastic is what you’re feeling. Don’t pull hard: old elastic can be brittle, and restringing is a job for a doll repairer.

Vinyl has no painted-over composition surface, and the color is in the material itself. Camelot calls the vinyl Shirleys durable and mass-produced. Our sources don’t describe the vinyl body construction in detail, so we haven’t listed it in the table.

Look at the eyes

Composition Shirleys usually have hazel sleep eyes. Kennett describes hazel eyes with upper hair lashes and painted brows, lower lashes and lips. WorthPoint says some of the larger composition dolls have flirty eyes that move from side to side.

On the vinyl dolls, Camelot says the 17- and 19-inch sizes came with either sleep eyes or flirty eyes. Eyes alone won’t separate the two eras, but they help once you know the material.

Measure her

The size ranges overlap only partly.

  • Composition: Doll Reference lists nine sizes, 11, 13½, 16, 17, 18, 20, 22, 25 and 27 inches. Doll Kingdom names 13 and 18 inches as the most common.
  • Vinyl: Doll Reference lists 12, 15, 17 and 19 inches for 1958–1963, plus a very rare 26-inch doll. The 12-inch is the most commonly found. The 1960 Playpal-size Shirley is listed at 35 inches by Doll Reference and 36 inches by Camelot and WorthPoint.

A 12- or 15-inch doll is more likely vinyl; an 11-, 13- or 13½-inch doll is more likely composition. A 17-inch doll could be either, so check the hair and mark. Measure from the top of the head to the heel with her legs straight, and remember that a full wig can add a little height.

Read the damage

Age shows differently on each material, and the pattern of wear is a useful clue.

Composition reacts to temperature. Doll Kingdom says it is subject to cracking and craze if exposed to extremes of temperature, and that the eyes tend to get cloudy. Fine crackling across the face, cheeks or limbs is the classic sign of a composition doll.

Vinyl ages through its plasticizers and through light. The RISD Museum explains that plasticizers migrate through the material and can leave a sticky residue on the surface over time, and it names plasticized PVC dolls such as Barbie and Ken as an example. Family Tree Magazine warns that fluorescent lights can turn vinyl dolls green. A tacky feel or an odd color cast points to vinyl, not composition.

Why the dates differ by a year

You’ll see the vinyl run start in either 1957 or 1958. Doll Reference and WorthPoint give 1958. The Strong National Museum of Play says Ideal switched from composition dolls to dolls of vinyl in 1957, and Kennett also dates the vinyl dolls 1957–1963. Either way, there is a gap of almost two decades between the two materials, so the hair and the mark leave little room for confusion.

A one-minute check, in order

  1. Hair: glued wig (composition) or rooted plugs (vinyl)?
  2. Neck mark: SHIRLEY TEMPLE in full (composition) or Ideal Doll with ST and a number (vinyl)?
  3. Surface: painted, hard, perhaps crazed (composition) or uniform in color with no paint layer (vinyl)?
  4. Height: compare with the size lists above.
  5. Damage: crackling and cloudy eyes, or stickiness and color change?

If the answers disagree, for example a rooted-hair doll with no ST mark, she may be a different issue or a different maker, so read the next section before deciding.

Not either one?

If she is vinyl but 16 inches with painted eyes, she is probably the later 1970s Ideal doll, not a 1950s one; Doll Reference records her neck mark as 1972 IDEAL TOY CORP. ST-14-H-213 Hong Kong. If she is composition but has no Shirley Temple or Ideal marks at all, she may be a look-alike: the Powerhouse Museum notes that many firms worldwide copied the doll and that those copies lack the marks.

Next steps

Sources