Shirley Temple Doll Molds and Head Variations Explained
Most composition Shirley Temples (1934–1939) come from Ideal's toddler molds in nine sizes from 11 to 27 inches, and one source says Ideal changed the face mold in 1936. Many apparent "mold" differences actually come from size, hand-painted coloring, eye type, or a different doll on the Shirley body, such as Snow White, Cinderella, Marama or a licensed or look-alike Shirley. The 1957 and 1972 vinyl dolls used completely new molds with their own ST size codes.
Why two Shirleys can look so different
Put two composition Shirley Temple dolls side by side and they often don’t match. One face looks rounder, one has rosier cheeks, one has a slightly different forehead. Before you decide you have a rare variant, it helps to know that several separate things can cause those differences:
- A real mold change. Ideal did alter the face during the composition years.
- Size. Each size needed its own mold, so proportions shift from one size to the next.
- Paint and finish. Cheek blush, lip color and complexion were applied by hand, and composition ages unevenly.
- A different doll entirely. Ideal reused the Shirley body (and sometimes the head) for other characters, licensed factories abroad made their own versions, and other companies made unlicensed look-alikes.
- A different generation. Vinyl Shirleys from 1957 and 1972 used completely new molds.
The rest of this guide goes through each one, with the marks that help you tell them apart.
The composition molds (1934–1939)
Ideal had permission from the Temple family and launched the composition doll in 1934. Doll Kingdom credits the original face design to Bernard Lipfert, with dimples in both cheeks, hazel sleep eyes and a golden mohair wig in ringlets. The Victoria and Albert Museum’s 22-inch example has trade catalogue entries from 1935 to 1939 (V&A).
The 1936 face change
Doll Kingdom states plainly that “in 1936 the Shirley face mold was changed” (Doll Kingdom). None of the sources we read describe exactly what changed. If you compare your own dolls, look at face shape, cheek fullness and forehead, but treat any “earlier face” or “later face” sorting as opinion unless the doll also has dated paperwork or clothing.
The same article says Ideal introduced a newer-looking Shirley in 1938, with curls worn close to the head and a side part. That is a hairstyle and styling change, so look at the wig and its set as well as the face.
Early and prototype marks
Very early and prototype dolls are a special case. In a Collectors Weekly discussion, one experienced collector says the early prototypes were marked “COP IDEAL N&TC” and some had a paper label inside the head, and links tin eyes with early dolls. The original poster later bought a doll they describe as a real prototype with that “COP Ideal N&TC” mark. This is collector testimony, not a published reference, but it tells you what to look for.
Size and mark table
Doll Reference lists composition Shirleys in 11, 13½, 16, 17, 18, 20, 22, 25 and 27 inches, all composition and jointed. Doll Kingdom gives the same range, calls 13 and 18 inches the most common, and calls 11 and 27 inches the rarest. Linda Hamer Kennett describes them as six pieces strung with elastic (Weekly View).
| Where to look | Mark styles recorded | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Head | SHIRLEY TEMPLE / IDEAL NOV. & TOY CO. | Doll Reference |
| Back | SHIRLEY TEMPLE in an arch | Doll Reference |
| Back | SHIRLEY TEMPLE in an arch, IDEAL N. & T. CO. | Doll Reference |
| Back | SHIRLEY TEMPLE with “Ideal” inside a diamond | Doll Reference |
| Nape and back | SHIRLEY TEMPLE in an arch over the size number (22) | V&A |
| Inside head (early) | COP IDEAL N&TC, sometimes a paper label | Collectors Weekly thread |
Most composition Shirleys are marked “Shirley Temple” on both head and body, along with Ideal and the size (Doll Kingdom). The Filmic Light blog adds that Shirley body molds are marked on the upper back, often with the size number. So a different mark style on two dolls usually tells you about the size or the production run, not necessarily a different face mold.
Eyes, which change the look more than you’d expect
The usual eyes were hazel sleep eyes, but Doll Kingdom records colors ranging from pale brown to true brown, a few blue, and some metal eyes in brown or blue. Flirty-eye versions were made, and a 27-inch blue-eyed version exists. Eyes also tend to cloud with age. Two dolls from the same mold can look very different just because of eye color or clouding.
Same body, different doll
Ideal made good use of its Shirley molds, and these dolls are the most common source of confusion.
- Snow White (1938). Doll Reference says one of three Ideal Snow White dolls used the Shirley Temple mold. It was 11 inches, all composition, with a black mohair wig and dimples in the cheeks. The Filmic Light blog adds that the Snow Whites used the Shirley body mold “but not always her face mold,” and that the larger sizes had a different face.
- Cinderella. Doll Reference says it used the Shirley body mold. The 13½-inch doll is marked “Shirley Temple 13” on the back or is unmarked, and the 18-inch doll is marked “Shirley Temple” on the head and “Shirley Temple 18” on the back. The 22-inch doll has “Ideal” in a diamond with “USA” on the head instead.
- Hawaiian Shirley (“Marama”, 1939–1940). This used the Shirley head and body mold in 13 and 18 inches, according to Doll Reference. The 13-inch doll can be marked “Ideal 13” or “Shirley Temple” on the back.
- Ginger (about 1934–1937). Doll Reference says Ginger used the same jointed composition body as the later Shirleys and is unmarked or faintly marked. Filmic Light’s rule of thumb: a single chin dimple means a Ginger head, while Shirley has a dimple on each side of the mouth.
So a doll marked “Shirley Temple” on the back with the wrong face, the wrong wig color or a chin dimple may be one of these, and not a Shirley head variant.
A different head mold altogether: the Shirley Temple Baby
The Shirley Temple Baby (1935) is not a variation of the toddler doll. Doll Reference describes a composition shoulder-plate head on a cloth, kapok-stuffed body, with molded hair (wigged or not), flirty sleep eyes and an open mouth with teeth. It was sold through Sears in sizes from about 16 to 27 inches. Both Doll Reference and Kennett note it is marked “Shirley Temple” on the head only, so an unmarked body is normal for this doll.
Licensed and look-alike Shirleys
Doll Kingdom notes that the Reliable Toy Company of Canada made a 20-inch Shirley under license from Ideal in 1936, and that it is marked “Reliable.” The same source names other licensed factories in Spain, England, France and Australia. A Shirley from one of these may have a face that differs from Ideal’s, and a non-Ideal mark doesn’t automatically make it a fake.
Unlicensed knock-offs were common too. Doll Kingdom mentions a modern maker in Texas producing reproduction composition Shirleys whose signature is on the shoe, so a reproduction can look unmarked once the shoes are gone. Filmic Light and Doll Reference both describe Shirley look-alikes without dimples. A mismatched face plus no marks at all should make you suspicious.
The vinyl generations
1957 to early 1960s
When Ideal brought Shirley back in vinyl alongside the Shirley Temple’s Storybook television series, it used entirely new molds. Kennett gives five sizes from 12 to 36 inches, marked with the inch size and “ST” or “STN” (Weekly View). The Camelot Dolls blog lists 12, 15, 17 and 19 inches plus a 36-inch Playpal size, calls the 12-inch the most common, and says the dolls are marked “Ideal Doll” with the size code (for example ST-12 or ST-15) on the back of the head and on the back. It also notes that the 17- and 19-inch dolls came with either sleep eyes or flirty eyes. Doll Reference records the codes ST12N and ST17N for Ideal Shirley Temple.
Sources disagree about the exact start year and whether the 12-inch belongs to the first season, so use the mark more than the year.
| Size | Mark pattern | Eyes |
|---|---|---|
| 12” | IDEAL DOLL / ST-12 (also ST12N recorded) | not specified |
| 15” | IDEAL DOLL / ST-15 | not specified |
| 17” | IDEAL DOLL / ST-17 (also ST17N recorded) | sleep or flirty |
| 19” | IDEAL DOLL / ST-19 | sleep or flirty |
| 36” | Playpal size | not specified |
1972–1975
The Strong National Museum of Play holds a 16-inch vinyl Shirley that Ideal made in 1972 and 1973, usually seen in the red polka-dot “Stand Up and Cheer” dress (Strong Museum via Google Arts & Culture). Doll Reference describes it as having rooted blonde hair, brown painted eyes and a plastic jointed body, marked on the neck “1972 IDEAL TOY CORP. ST-14-H-213 Hong Kong” and on the back “1972 2M-5534-2.” Painted eyes alone separate this doll from the 1950s sleep-eye dolls at a glance.
Quick checklist for comparing two dolls
- Material: composition (prone to crazing and cracking) or vinyl (with rooted hair)?
- Marks: read the head and the upper back, and note the size number.
- Measure: a different height usually means a different size mold, which changes the proportions.
- Dimples: two cheek dimples point to Shirley; a single chin dimple points to Ginger.
- Eyes: sleep, flirty, metal, or painted (1970s).
- Wig and coloring: remember that blush and complexion vary doll to doll and with age.
- Other names: consider Snow White, Cinderella, Marama, Reliable and look-alikes before calling it a new Shirley variant.
Questions people ask
Did Ideal use more than one face mold for the composition Shirley Temple?
Yes. Doll Kingdom reports that the face mold was changed in 1936. The sources we found don't describe the exact differences, so sorting dolls by face type is still a matter of collector judgment.
My doll says "Shirley Temple" on the back but the face looks wrong. Why?
Ideal reused the Shirley body for Cinderella, Snow White and Marama, and some of those carry Shirley marks on the back. Check the head mark, the dimples (two cheek dimples for Shirley, a chin dimple for Ginger) and the wig color.
What do ST-12 or ST-17 marks mean?
They are the size codes on 1950s–60s vinyl Shirleys by Ideal: ST plus the height in inches, sometimes with an N (for example ST12N). The 1972 vinyl doll uses a longer code, ST-14-H-213, with a 1972 date.
Is a Shirley marked "Reliable" a fake?
No. Reliable Toy Company of Canada made Shirley under license from Ideal, and its dolls are marked Reliable.