Shirley Temple Doll Outfits by Film: Heidi, Little Miss Marker, Bright Eyes, The Little Princess and More
Ideal dressed its 1930s composition Shirley Temple dolls in outfits inspired by her films, from the plaid Lollipop dress of Bright Eyes (1934) to the tiered gown of The Little Colonel (1935) and the dress and apron of Heidi (1937). Match a dress by its details and its cloth label (NRA or non-NRA rayon) rather than by name alone, because designs came in several fabrics and catalogs sometimes credit one dress to two films. The 1957 and later vinyl dolls had their own film outfits, including Heidi and Wee Willie Winkie.
Ideal obtained the rights to a Shirley Temple doll in 1934, and new dresses followed her films for the rest of the decade. Matching a doll’s dress to a film is one of the most rewarding parts of collecting, but it is also where most of the confusion lies. Many “movie” dresses were loose interpretations, the same design was cut from several fabrics, and two catalog entries can credit one dress to two different films.
This guide works film by film through the outfits documented in auction catalogs from Theriault’s, the doll auction house that has sold Shirley Temple’s own childhood collection along with many private collections. Every outfit below is one a catalog described and credited to a film. Film years come from Wikipedia’s Shirley Temple filmography. If you still need to work out which doll you have, start with Identify Your Doll and the 1930s composition identification guide.
How the film outfits worked
“Inspired by” is the usual wording. Catalogs seldom call a factory dress an exact copy. A blue dimity dress with polka-dot panels, for example, is described as one that “was inspired by a dress worn by Shirley in the film Captain January”. Expect the doll dress to capture the look of the screen costume (the plaid, the bow tie, the bonnet) rather than copy every seam.
One design, several fabrics. Ideal reused a successful pattern in different colors and prints. The striped Curly Top dress “was made in a variety of striped fabrics”. The Bright Eyes “Lollipop” plaid turns up in yellow, red and two blues. A dress in an unfamiliar color can still be factory original.
The same dress came in many doll sizes. The 1930s composition outfits below appear on dolls from 13 inches to 27 inches. The 1950s vinyl film outfits are catalogued on 12-, 15- and 17-inch dolls, and Ideal’s 1982–83 movie-costume series came in 8- and 12-inch sizes. Very elaborate costumes, such as the Little Colonel gown, are documented on the larger composition dolls.
Publicity photos count too. Some dresses copy what Shirley wore in studio portraits, not on screen. A blue dotted dress was inspired by publicity photos of Shirley taken when Baby Take a Bow came out in 1934, and the pink pleated organdy “dancing dress” is linked to early publicity photographs rather than a film.
Reading the dress label
Auction catalogs routinely note a dress’s cloth label, and they record three kinds:
- NRA label. The label carries the Blue Eagle mark of the National Recovery Administration, which asked businesses to display “the blue eagle logo, an emblem signifying NRA participation”. The Supreme Court struck down that program on May 27, 1935, so an NRA label suggests a dress from the early years of production.
- Non-NRA rayon label. These are found on dresses for later films, such as Captain January (1936), and also on later runs of early designs.
- Size-only or unlabeled pieces. Some genuine factory pieces carry only a size: the Poor Little Rich Girl pajamas in one lot were “tagged only 18”. Others carry no label at all.
The NRA line is not sharp. The Bright Eyes plaid dress turns up with both NRA and non-NRA labels, and the 1935 Curly Top striped dress still has an NRA label. Read the label as a rough clue to when a dress was made, never as proof. Original or Reproduction? covers checking that a dress belongs with its doll.
Composition-era outfits by film, 1934–1938
| Film (year) | Outfit as catalogued | Fabric and details | Label noted | Doll sizes seen |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Stand Up and Cheer! (1934) | Red polka-dot dress; blue Scottie dress with romper and hat | Dot print; Scottie appliqué | Original cloth label | 18” |
| Little Miss Marker (1934) | Red cotton dress with organdy collar and pinafore | Lace-edged organdy collar and pinafore | Tagged | 18” |
| Baby Take a Bow (1934, publicity) | Blue dress with white dots and a contrasting dotted collar | Cotton; offered in blue or red | — | 18” |
| Bright Eyes (1934) | Plaid “Lollipop” dress with bow tie | Yellow, red, blue or nubby blue cotton plaid | NRA and non-NRA rayon both seen | 13”, 18”, 20”, 25” |
| Bright Eyes (1934) | White corduroy coat and cloche with foxtail trim | From the film’s final scene | Rayon | 25” |
| The Little Colonel (1935) | Tiered gown, pantalets and feathered bonnet | Taffeta or organdy, in pink or yellow among others; some with hooped petticoat | Shirley Temple tag; non-NRA rayon | 22”, 27” |
| Our Little Girl (1935) | Blue dimity dress printed with music notes | Dimity; worn with celluloid pin | NRA rayon | 18”, 27” |
| Our Little Girl (1935) | Blue piqué dress with two appliqué Scottie dogs | Leashes fastened to pearl buttons | NRA | 15”, 18” |
| Curly Top (1935) | Striped cotton dress with pearl-button front | Several stripe fabrics | NRA cloth label | 13” |
| Curly Top (1935) | Black velvet overlay over taffeta, with velvet cap | Floral embroidery | Non-NRA rayon | 27” |
| Curly Top (1935) | Pleated organdy dress with blue dots; “starburst” organdy variation | Organdy; ruffled collar, blue sash | Original cloth label | 13”, 18” |
| The Littlest Rebel (1935) | Yellow polka-dot dress | Dot print | Original cloth label | 18” |
| Captain January (1936) | Smocked dresses in blue flowered and yellow prints | Smocking | Original cloth label | 18”, 25” |
| Captain January (1936) | Dimity or piqué dress with polka-dot panels and sleeves | Blue dimity or red piqué | Non-NRA rayon; Ideal tag | 16”, 22” |
| Captain January (1936) | Middy uniform with bell bottoms and sailor cap | Red buttons on bell bottoms | — | 18” |
| Poor Little Rich Girl (1936) | “Emblem dress” | Rare color variation recorded | — | 25” |
| Poor Little Rich Girl (1936) | Polka-dot silk pajamas | Silk | Size only (“18”) | 18” |
| Poor Little Rich Girl (1936) | Red cotton sailor dress with matching cap | Cotton | Non-NRA | 27” |
| Heidi (1937) | Dress and apron | Factory costume, scarce | Tagged | 16” |
A few notes on the table:
- Two films, one Scottie dress. One catalog lists a “blue Scottie dress from Stand Up and Cheer with matching romper and hat”, while two other lots title the blue piqué dress with appliqué Scotties as a Scottie dress from Our Little Girl. These may be two different Scottie designs, or one design credited two ways. Describe yours by its details (romper, leashes, buttons) rather than by a film title alone. The same trunk lot lists the yellow polka-dot dress under the title “The Little Rebel”; the film is The Littlest Rebel.
- Little Miss Marker. The one catalogued factory outfit is a red cotton dress with a lace-edged organdy collar and pinafore on an 18-inch doll from about 1934, still with its original tag.
- Bright Eyes plaid. Catalogued examples include yellow plaid with a yellow bow tie and an NRA rayon label, blue nubby plaid with a red bow tie, blue plaid with a blue bow tie and red plaid with a red bow tie on a 13-inch doll. All are linked to “On the Good Ship Lollipop,” which Shirley sings in Bright Eyes. The corduroy coat and foxtail cloche is the same film’s other documented outfit.
- The Little Colonel. The 27-inch dolls wear a tiered taffeta gown with pantalets and a feathered bonnet. One even has a hooped petticoat and a floral garland necklace. A 22-inch doll has a pink organdy version with a non-NRA tag, and a later 27-inch example is in yellow taffeta with a sunbonnet, its costume marked “Shirley Temple Doll, Registered US pat. Off.”
- Our Little Girl. The music-note dimity appears on an 18-inch doll with an NRA rayon tag and celluloid pin and on a 27-inch flirty-eyed doll.
- Curly Top. Besides the striped dress, there is the velvet-over-taffeta costume and a pleated organdy dress with blue dots.
- Captain January. Its outfits include the blue dimity and red piqué polka-dot dresses, the middy uniform and a smock dress shown alongside a Bright Eyes coat.
- Poor Little Rich Girl. The outfits are the emblem dress, the silk pajamas and the red sailor dress, which came with its original box.
- Heidi. The composition example is a 16-inch doll from about 1937 in a tagged dress and apron. The catalog dates the film to 1936, but Heidi was released in 1937.
Studio-made, one-of-a-kind and later costumes
Some film costumes on composition dolls never came from Ideal’s factory. Shirley Temple recalled that Fox’s wardrobe woman, Ande, would dress a doll in a small copy of a costume Shirley chose, made from leftover scraps of the real fabric. A Rebecca of Sunnybrook Farm doll from the family archives wears blue chambray overalls and a plaid shirt and carries a tiny piglet. A 13-inch doll in a kilt, sporran and twill jacket from Wee Willie Winkie is also catalogued as made at Fox Studios. Pieces like these are unique, and their value depends on their documented history.
Not every film costume on an old doll is factory or studio work, either. One 18-inch doll’s brown wool jacket, tam and plaid skirt from Wee Willie Winkie is described as a “1940s vintage costume”, not an Ideal original. An unlabeled film-style dress may be a period home sewing project, which is a lovely thing to own but is a different item from a tagged factory dress.
The Little Princess (1939) is a favorite with collectors, but none of the catalogs read for this guide recorded a factory composition outfit credited to it. If you have a labeled Little Princess dress on a composition doll, treat it as something to document carefully, not something to assume.
Vinyl-era film outfits, 1957 onward
Ideal brought Shirley back in vinyl, and, as The Strong National Museum of Play notes, the switch came in 1957 alongside her television series and the TV release of her films. Vinyl outfits are often found with extras that help confirm them: a wrist tag, a dress tag, a signature pin or button, a vinyl purse and a box. For dating the vinyl dolls themselves, see Dolls by Era.
| Film | Vinyl outfit as catalogued | Doll marks / size | Year |
|---|---|---|---|
| Heidi | Red floral dress, white pinafore, green corset vest with red lacing, green felt cap | ST-15-N, 15” | 1958 |
| Heidi | Green felt vest and cap, in a Fairyland Heroine window box | 15” | c. 1958 |
| Heidi | Organdy blouse with embroidered suspenders and red-and-white striped skirt | 12” | c. 1958 |
| Wee Willie Winkie | Red plaid dress, taupe snap jacket, cap with Scottish tassel | ST-17, 17” | 1958 |
| Wee Willie Winkie | Plaid taffeta dress, tan jacket, red flannel tam | 17” | c. 1958 |
| Wee Willie Winkie | Scottish costume with cap | 12” | c. 1959 |
| Poor Little Rich Girl | Blue cotton sailor dress with middy collar and matching hat | ST-15-N, 15” | 1960 reissue |
Sources for these rows: the Heidi with corset vest, the Fairyland Heroine Heidi, the 12-inch Heidi, the ST-17 Winkie, the tan-jacket Winkie, the 12-inch Winkie and the 1960 sailor dress.
The two Heidi outfits are quite different, so don’t rule out a vinyl Heidi because it lacks the green vest.
1970s and 1980s issues
Later Ideal dolls reuse the film theme, and their names can mislead. The Strong records that Ideal made a 16-inch vinyl doll in 1972 and 1973, usually in a red polka-dot Stand Up and Cheer costume. The museum’s own example of that doll is catalogued as a “Heidi” doll. Then, in 1982–83, Ideal released an 8-inch and 12-inch series of Shirley in various movie costumes, including Captain January. A Stand Up and Cheer polka-dot dress on a vinyl doll may therefore be from the 1970s rather than the 1930s, so check the doll’s body before the dress.
Matching a dress to a film: a quick checklist
- Identify the doll first. Composition or vinyl, size and marks narrow the possibilities before you look at the dress.
- Look for the label. Note whether it’s NRA, non-NRA rayon or a size number, and whether it is sewn in the way the other seams are.
- Describe the details, not the film. Fabric, trim, buttons, bow tie, matching hat or romper. These are what catalogs record.
- Compare with documented examples. Use the tables above, and allow for color variations of the same design.
- Expect disagreement. When respected sources credit a dress to different films, record both.
- Keep provenance. Studio-made and family-archive costumes depend on their paper trail.
Questions people ask
Were Ideal's Shirley Temple movie dresses exact copies of the film costumes?
Usually not. Auction catalogs describe most factory dresses as inspired by a film costume, capturing its look (the plaid, bow tie or bonnet) rather than copying every detail. A few one-of-a-kind doll costumes were made at Fox from scraps of the real costume fabric, but those were not factory products.
Does an NRA label on the dress date my doll?
It is a rough clue. The NRA program behind the Blue Eagle was struck down on May 27, 1935, so an NRA label suggests an early dress. But the same designs were made with both NRA and non-NRA labels, and dresses moved between dolls over the years, so check the doll's own marks too.
My dress is a film design in a color I can't find. Is it wrong?
Not necessarily. Ideal made popular designs in several fabrics: the Curly Top striped dress came in a variety of stripes, and the Bright Eyes Lollipop plaid is recorded in yellow, red and two blues.
Is there a factory Little Princess outfit for the composition doll?
None of the auction catalogs read for this guide recorded one. If you have a labeled Little Princess dress on a composition doll, document it carefully rather than assume it.
How can I tell a 1930s Stand Up and Cheer dress from a later one?
Check the doll first. Ideal's 1972–73 16-inch vinyl doll usually wore a red polka-dot Stand Up and Cheer costume, so a polka-dot dress on a vinyl doll is likely from the 1970s. A 1930s dress belongs on a composition doll and usually has a cloth label.