All My Dolls

Reproduction or Original? How to Spot Fake and Later-Issue Shirley Temple Dolls

November 15, 2026

A Shirley Temple doll with blonde ringlet curls
C. E. Price · Public domain

What you need

  • Good light, ideally daylight or a bright lamp you can angle
  • Magnifying glass or phone camera with zoom, for faint marks
  • Tape measure, to check the doll's height against known sizes
  • Soft cloth or cotton gloves for handling
  • Notebook or phone to record every mark exactly as written

Steps

  1. Measure the doll from the top of the head to the heel and note the height.
  2. Look at the back of the neck under angled light and write down every letter and number exactly.
  3. Check the middle and upper back for a second mark.
  4. Identify the material: composition (wood pulp and glue, often with fine crazing), vinyl, plastic or porcelain.
  5. Examine the hair: a glued-on mohair wig in ringlets, or hair rooted into a vinyl scalp.
  6. Look at the eyes: sleep eyes that close, flirty eyes that also move side to side, or painted eyes.
  7. On a composition doll, check the open mouth for teeth and a felt tongue.
  8. Look inside the dress seams for a woven or cloth label and record its wording.
  9. Check for a pin or brooch and note its picture and wording.
  10. Inspect the shoes and their soles, and ask whether the original shoes are present.
  11. Compare everything against the table below and note anything that doesn't fit.

Most Shirley Temple dolls that turn up in attics and estate sales fall into one of four groups: the original 1930s Ideal composition dolls, later Ideal vinyl issues (1957 onward, and again in the 1970s and 1980s), porcelain collector dolls from companies such as the Danbury Mint, and copies made without a licence, from Depression-era look-alikes to modern reproductions. All four can be collectible. The aim here is to tell which one you have, so you can describe it accurately.

The quickest clues are the marks on the neck and back and the material the doll is made of. Hair, eyes, clothing labels and pins then confirm or contradict what the marks say.

The groups at a glance

1930s Ideal composition Ideal vinyl, 1957–1960s Ideal vinyl, 1970s and 1980s Porcelain collector dolls (e.g. Danbury Mint) Unlicensed copies and look-alikes
Material Composition (wood pulp and glue) Vinyl head with rooted hair Vinyl head, plastic jointed body (16-inch doll) Porcelain Composition or other materials
Feel and ageing Hard and matte; prone to crazing and cracking with heat and cold Smooth vinyl Smooth vinyl Hard, cold porcelain Varies
Marks “Shirley Temple” on the head and usually the body, with Ideal and the size; first-year dolls may carry “COP” “Ideal Doll” plus a size code, e.g. “Ideal Doll ST12”, on head and back 16-inch doll: “1972 Ideal Toy Corp. ST-14-H-213 Hong Kong” on the neck Maker’s mark Often no Shirley Temple mark; some modern reproductions are signed on the shoe
Hair Golden blonde mohair wig, about 52 sausage curls Rooted Saran hair Rooted blonde hair — May differ from the mohair ringlet wig
Eyes Sleep eyes, usually hazel; a few blue; some metal; often clouded with age Sleep eyes; 17- and 19-inch dolls may have flirty eyes 16-inch doll: brown painted eyes — Varies
Mouth Open, six teeth, felt tongue, dimples Open smile Open smile with teeth (16-inch) — Varies
Clothing Film outfits carry a woven label with her signature sewn into the seam Ideal clothing 1970s 16-inch doll usually in a red polka-dot Stand Up and Cheer dress Maker’s own clothing Labels missing or not matching

Pins: some dolls have a brooch or tag with her picture reading “The World’s Darling / Genuine Shirley Temple Doll” or “My Friend / Shirley Temple” (Antiques Know How). A pin supports an identification, but pins can be moved between dolls, so check it against the marks.

1930s Ideal composition: the originals

Ideal made composition Shirley Temple dolls from 1934 to about 1939, designed by Bernard Lipfert (Collectibles Insurance Services). Writing in Antique Doll Collector (April 2001, reproduced by Doll Kingdom), Judith Izen lists these features:

  • Sizes: 11, 13, 16, 17, 18, 20, 22, 25 and 27 inches. The 13-inch and 18-inch dolls are the most common, so your measurement is a useful first check.
  • Marks: most are marked “Shirley Temple” on the head and body, along with Ideal and the size.
  • Face: dimples in both cheeks; sleep eyes, usually hazel, ranging from pale brown to true brown, with a few blue and some brown or blue metal eyes. The eyes often cloud over time. The mouth is open with six teeth and a felt tongue. The face mould changed in 1936.
  • Wig: golden blonde mohair in about 52 sausage curls. The 1938 “Shirley Temple at Nine” doll has curls set close to the head and a side part.
  • Shoes: white oilcloth with centre snaps, usually with a silver buckle on the toe.
  • Clothing: outfits copied from her films carried a woven label with her signature sewn into the seam.
  • Material: composition (wood pulp and glue), which can crack or craze with temperature extremes.

A collector writing on Collectors Weekly reports that first-year dolls were stamped with “COP” (copyright pending), and that once Ideal had the copyright the dolls said “Shirley Temple” on the head and back.

Ideal also licensed factories outside the United States, including Reliable in Canada, Hijos Francisco Merin Perez in Spain, Richards, Son & Allwin in England, Printemps Sapac in Paris and S. Hoffnung & Co in Australia (Izen via Doll Kingdom). A doll with a Reliable mark, for example, can be a genuine licensed doll and not a fake.

Later Ideal vinyl issues

In 1957 Ideal switched from composition to vinyl, to coincide with Shirley Temple’s new television series and the release of her films on television (The Strong National Museum of Play, via Google Arts & Culture).

  • 1957 to the 1960s: dolls are marked “Ideal Doll” with a size code such as “ST12” on the back of the head and on the back. Sizes include 12, 15, 17 and 19 inches, plus a 36-inch Playpal. The 12-inch is the most common. The 17- and 19-inch dolls came with sleep eyes or flirty eyes, which rock from side to side (Camelot Dolls).
  • 1970s: a 16-inch vinyl doll, usually in a red polka-dot Stand Up and Cheer dress (The Strong, via Google Arts & Culture). Doll Reference records the neck mark as “1972 IDEAL TOY CORP. ST-14-H-213 Hong Kong” and the back mark as “1972 2M-5534-2”, with brown painted eyes, rooted blonde hair and an open smiling mouth with teeth. It dates this doll 1973–75, with four extra outfits sold separately in 1974–75 (Doll Reference), so the “1972” in the mark is not necessarily the year your doll was made.
  • 1982–83: Ideal released 8-inch and 12-inch dolls in various film costumes (The Strong, via Google Arts & Culture).

A vinyl doll with rooted hair is never a 1930s doll, however old its clothes look.

Porcelain collector dolls

The Danbury Mint made porcelain Shirley Temple collector dolls after Ideal’s production ended, some as large as 36 inches (Antiques Know How). These were made as collector’s items and not to pass as 1930s dolls, but once the box and paperwork are gone they can confuse an heir. The material settles it: the 1930s Ideal Shirleys were composition, not porcelain.

Copies and look-alikes

The doll’s success brought many imitations. Collectors note that cheaper copycat dolls were sold during the Depression and that many companies made Shirley look-alikes, while genuine Ideal dolls are marked with the Shirley Temple name (Collectors Weekly). Izen adds that other manufacturers made unlicensed knock-offs, and that a Texas maker produces reproduction composition Shirleys that are signed on the shoe. Dealers sometimes remove the shoes, so check the feet and ask about them (Izen via Doll Kingdom).

Red flags checklist

  • ☐ No “Shirley Temple” mark on a composition doll. Check both the neck and the back before deciding.
  • ☐ A different maker’s name in the mark, unless it is one of Ideal’s licensed foreign makers.
  • ☐ Porcelain, or rooted hair, on a doll sold as 1930s.
  • ☐ A height that matches no known size, or a size in the mark that doesn’t match the doll.
  • ☐ No crazing, clouding or wear anywhere on a composition doll said to be 90 years old. Composition crazes easily, and the eyes tend to cloud.
  • ☐ Missing shoes on a composition doll offered as original. The shoes are where at least one reproduction maker signs.
  • ☐ Hair that isn’t a mohair ringlet wig on a doll sold as a 1930s original. It may be a copy or a replacement wig.
  • ☐ A pin or label doing all the work. Pins and dresses move between dolls; they support an identification but can’t make one.

If several boxes are ticked, or the marks don’t match anything here, the next step is a dedicated reference such as Tonya Bervaldi-Camaratta’s The Complete Guide to Shirley Temple Dolls and Collectibles or Judith Izen’s Collector’s Guide to Ideal Dolls, or a doll appraiser who can handle the doll in person.

Common mistakes

  • Treating any blonde ringlet doll as a Shirley Temple: many look-alikes were sold without her name.
  • Assuming an unmarked composition doll is an Ideal Shirley.
  • Reading the 1972 mark as the year the doll was made: the 16-inch doll kept that mark into later years.
  • Trusting the outfit or pin alone; both can be moved from one doll to another.
  • Missing a reproduction because its signed shoes were removed.

Sources