Shirley Temple Doll FAQ: Answers for People Who Just Inherited One
Start by finding the marks on the back of her neck and upper back and working out what she's made of: composition (1930s), vinyl (late 1950s on) or porcelain (later collector dolls, made from the 1990s). Don't wash, re-curl or repaint her; dust gently, store her in a closed cabinet away from sunlight and heat swings, and keep every scrap of original clothing. For a value, use an independent appraiser from a professional appraisers' society; museums generally won't appraise.
Inheriting a Shirley Temple doll usually brings the same handful of questions. Here are short answers, each with a pointer to the deeper guides on this site. If you only do one thing today, find the marks: they answer most of the other questions.
Is she a real Shirley Temple?
The dolls most people mean are the ones Ideal made in the 1930s. The Powerhouse Museum puts total sales at over six million and notes that many firms worldwide copied the doll; Doll Kingdom gives a lower figure of over one and a half million sold from 1934 to 1939, so estimates vary. The copies, collectors’ “Shirley types”, do not have ‘Shirley Temple’ or ‘Ideal’ marks.
So the first check is the marks. Composition Ideal Shirleys, apart from the earliest dolls, are marked SHIRLEY TEMPLE on both the head and back. The earliest dolls of 1934 are different: Powerhouse says that until copyright was obtained, they were printed on the back of the head with COP, for “Copyright Pending”. Lift the wig edge at the nape gently and look with a light held low; the marks are raised and easy to miss. Then check between the shoulder blades.
Two cautions:
- A back mark alone isn’t proof. Ideal used the Shirley body on other dolls, and Doll Reference lists an 18” Cinderella marked Shirley Temple on head and back.
- A non-Ideal mark isn’t automatically a fake. Reliable of Canada made Shirleys under license from Ideal, and Ideal licensed factories in Spain, England, France and Australia too.
Our step-by-step composition identification guide walks through marks, sizes, eyes, wig, pin and tags. For other materials, start at Identify Your Doll.
How old is she?
The material gives you the decade:
| What she’s made of | What it suggests |
|---|---|
| Hard, painted composition, often with fine crackling; glued-on mohair wig | Ideal composition, 1934–1939 |
| Cloth body with composition head and limbs | The composition Shirley Temple baby, mid-1930s |
| Vinyl with rooted hair, marked “Ideal Doll” plus an ST size code | Ideal vinyl, late 1950s to early 1960s |
| Vinyl, 16 inches, painted eyes, neck marked “1972 IDEAL TOY CORP. ST-14-H-213 Hong Kong” | Ideal, sold 1973–1975 |
| Vinyl, 8 or 12 inches, in a movie costume | Ideal’s 1982–83 series |
| Porcelain | A collector doll, such as Danbury Mint’s porcelain Shirleys; WorthPoint says collector dolls in porcelain have been made since the 1990s |
A year molded into vinyl is the mold date, not always the year she was made: the 16-inch doll is marked 1972 but Doll Reference dates her sale to 1973–1975. The full timeline, with sizes and mark codes for each run, is in Shirley Temple Dolls by Year, and Dolls by Era gives the bigger picture.
If you suspect she’s a later copy rather than a later issue, see Reproduction or Original?.
What is she worth?
We don’t publish prices here: they change, and a number without seeing the doll misleads more than it helps. What we can tell you is what moves the value up or down, so you can describe her well to an appraiser or buyer.
- Condition. Collectors look for original ringlet hairdo, original clothing, minimal crazing, and clear eyes.
- Box and pin. Doll Kingdom notes the doll is worth more if the original box and button are present.
- Outfit. WorthPoint says value is determined in large part by the rarity of the outfit she wears, naming the Texas Ranger costume, the Bright Eyes aviator outfit and the Curly Top dress with appliquéd velvet jacket as sought after.
- Size. Among the composition dolls, the smallest and largest are the most sought after.
- Era. WorthPoint says collectors seek the Ideal dolls most, especially the 1930s composition dolls and the 36-inch vinyl Playpal.
Where can I get her appraised?
Museums generally won’t appraise. The United Federation of Doll Clubs (UFDC) museum, for example, explains that federal law prevents the museum from providing identification services or appraisal values for donated items, and it points people to the regional branches of the Appraisers Association of America, the American Society of Appraisers or the International Society of Appraisers.
Before you contact one, write down everything you’ve found: the exact wording of every mark, her height, material, eye type and what she’s wearing. Take clear photos of the face, the marks, the whole doll front and back, and any tags, pins or box.
An independent appraiser who isn’t offering to buy the doll is the safest route. If the appraisal is for insurance, tax or an estate, tell the appraiser up front, because that changes what kind of report you need. Questions about taxes or estates belong with your own advisers.
Should I clean her?
Go very gently, and less is more. Composition is made of wood pulp and glue, and it cracks and crazes with extremes of temperature. Conservators are wary of water on it too: describing a treatment on papier-mâché toys, the McCord Stewart Museum notes that composition material can be damaged if wet with water. To be safe, keep water, solvents and household cleaners away from her face and body. Family Tree Magazine’s advice is to remove built-up grime before storing a doll but to be careful your well-intentioned efforts don’t cause damage.
A soft brush or cloth for dust is about as far as most owners should go. Anything more, such as lifting paint, reattaching a loose limb or restringing, is a job for a professional. The American Institute for Conservation’s Find a Professional Member directory lists conservators by specialty, and “Dolls” is one of the options under Objects.
Two habits help: wash your hands before handling her and skip hand lotion first, and keep food well away.
Her face is crackled and her eyes are cloudy. Is she ruined?
No. Fine crackling (crazing) is common on composition, and the eyes on these dolls tend to get cloudy. Both affect condition and value, but they don’t change what she is. Resist the urge to fix either yourself; a bad repair does more harm to value than honest age.
How should I store or display her?
Family Tree Magazine’s heirloom-doll guidance, in short:
- Not in airtight plastic. Sealed plastic containers put dolls at risk for mold and mildew.
- A closed cabinet away from pets, dust and sunlight, in a temperature-controlled part of the house. That rules out most attics, garages and basements, which matters for composition because of how it reacts to heat and cold.
- Archival boxes rather than acidic wood or cardboard, with acid-free tissue or cloth as cushioning.
- Indirect light. Direct sunlight fades clothing and hair, and fluorescent light can turn vinyl dolls green.
- Check for pests. Inspect any doll for insects and eggs before adding her to a collection, especially before putting her near other dolls or textiles.
Should I change her clothes or wig?
You can dress her in something else, but keep the originals. Original clothing, shoes and accessories add value, so keep them even if you buy her new togs. Many 1930s Shirley dresses had a woven label featuring her signature sewn into the seam, so check seams before you put anything aside, and store the dress with the doll.
The same goes for the wig. Collectors value the original ringlet set, so don’t wash or re-curl it yourself.
I want to keep her in the family. What should I write down?
Record what you know while people still remember it: who owned her, where and when she was bought or given, and any repairs. Provenance adds to a doll’s story, and it’s exactly the kind of detail an appraiser or a museum will ask for. The UFDC museum, for example, asks would-be donors for materials, date, dimensions and any previous history, treatments, restorations, appraisals.
To compare her with other examples, browse the doll catalog.
Questions people ask
Is my Shirley Temple doll real?
Genuine Ideal composition Shirleys are usually marked SHIRLEY TEMPLE on the head and back. The earliest 1934 dolls are the exception: until copyright was obtained, the Powerhouse Museum says they were marked COP (Copyright Pending) on the back of the head. A doll with no Shirley Temple or Ideal mark at all is more likely a look-alike.
How old is my doll?
Composition points to 1934–1939; vinyl with rooted hair points to the late 1950s or later; porcelain usually means a collector doll made from the 1990s. The mark codes narrow it further.
Can I wash my composition doll?
It's best not to. Composition is wood pulp and glue and cracks with temperature extremes, and conservators treat composition material as something that can be damaged if wet. Dust lightly and ask a conservator about anything more.
Where can I get my doll appraised?
Museums generally won't appraise; the UFDC museum, for example, says federal law prevents it from appraising donated items. It suggests the Appraisers Association of America, the American Society of Appraisers or the International Society of Appraisers.
Should I buy her a new dress?
You can, but keep the original clothes, shoes and accessories with her; they add value even if she wears something else.